No. In California you have the legal right to choose your own auto body shop after an accident. Your insurer cannot require you to use a specific shop, cannot penalize you for choosing your own, and can only recommend a shop if you ask.
After a collision, one of the first things you'll hear from an insurance adjuster is a suggestion: "We can get you into one of our shops right away." It sounds helpful. But it leaves a lot of drivers wondering whether they're allowed to go somewhere else — and the answer, in California, is a clear yes.
California law: the choice is yours
Under the California Insurance Code, an insurance company cannot require that your repairs be completed at a specific auto body shop. In fact, the insurer is required to tell you that you have the right to select the repair facility of your choice — and it isn't supposed to steer you toward a particular shop unless you specifically ask for a recommendation.
Just as importantly, your insurer cannot penalize you for using an independent shop. Choosing your own repair facility will not raise your premium and will not reduce what the company owes on a covered claim.
What is "steering," and why do insurers do it?
"Steering" is the industry term for pushing a customer toward the insurer's own network shop — often called a Direct Repair Program (DRP) shop. It can be subtle: a warning that an outside shop will "slow down" your claim, that the repair "won't be guaranteed," or that you'll have to pay any difference yourself. None of that is true when you exercise your legal right to choose.
Insurers favor their DRP shops because those shops have agreed to the insurer's pricing, cycle-time targets, and often the use of cheaper aftermarket parts. That can be good for the insurer's costs — but it isn't always aligned with repairing your vehicle to the manufacturer's exact standard.
Been in an accident in the Inland Empire?
Green Tech Collision Center works with every major insurer and repairs your vehicle to OEM spec. We'll handle the claim for you.
Start My Free EstimateIs there any downside to choosing your own shop?
There's one nuance worth understanding. If you use the insurer's recommended shop, California law makes the insurer stand behind those repairs if something is done incorrectly. When you choose an independent shop, that guarantee comes from the shop itself instead — which is exactly why the shop you pick matters.
A quality independent shop actually gives you more control, not less: your car is repaired to its manufacturer's procedures, with the parts and the time the job genuinely requires, and backed by the shop's own guarantee. At Green Tech Collision Center, every repair is completed to OEM specification and backed by a complete satisfaction guarantee.
How to choose the right collision repair shop
Whether it's us or someone else, look for a shop that will tell you honestly how the repair will be done. Ask:
- Will you repair my vehicle to OEM (manufacturer) procedures, even if the insurer's estimate doesn't fully cover it?
- What parts will you use — OEM, aftermarket, or recycled — and will you tell me before you order them?
- Will you recalibrate my ADAS (driver-assist) systems after the repair?
- Do you provide a written repair plan up front and a matching itemized invoice?
- Do you back your work with a guarantee?
The shop's answers tell you everything. A shop competing on the lowest insurance estimate will answer differently than one competing on doing the repair correctly.
The bottom line
You are never obligated to use your insurance company's shop. The decision is yours by law — and it's an important one, because the shop you choose determines whether your vehicle is truly restored or just made to look repaired. Choose the shop that will do it right.
This article is general information for California drivers, not legal advice. For questions about your specific policy or claim, consult your insurer or an attorney.